The idea behind the film

Replace every part. Still the same ship?

An old thought experiment, an 18 second film, and a question that gets harder the longer you hold it: your body has been replacing itself the whole time you have been you.

Add Mindfuse as a preferred source on Google

An animated wooden ship on dark water, its planks lit one by one as they are replaced.

Watch on YouTube

The idea

What the film says, slowly

The ship belonged to Theseus, the hero who sailed home to Athens after facing the Minotaur. The Athenians kept it for centuries as a monument. Wood rots, so whenever a plank gave out, a new one went in. Plutarch, writing around the year 100, says the ship became a standing example among philosophers: some held it was still the same ship, others that it was not. Nobody had moved it, nobody had renamed it, and yet at some point not a single original piece was left.

Centuries later, the English philosopher Thomas Hobbes made the puzzle sharper. Suppose someone had collected every old plank as it was removed and, years later, built a second ship from them. Now there are two ships. One has been on display the whole time and shares nothing with the original but its shape. The other is made of the original wood but was built last week. Which one is the ship of Theseus? Whatever you answer, you have to give up something you believed about what makes a thing itself.

The film ends by turning the question on you. A red blood cell lives about four months, then it is broken down and replaced by a new one. The blood carrying oxygen through you right now is not the blood you had in the summer. Other cells are replaced at their own pace, and a few, like most of the neurons in your brain, stay with you for life. You are a ship of replaced planks that still answers to the same name.

There are a few honest ways out. You can say that being the same thing is about the pattern, not the material: the plan of the ship, the shape of your life. You can say it is about the unbroken story: the ship was never two ships at once, and you have been one continuous person from your first breath. Or you can say that "the same" was never a fact about ships or bodies at all, only a word we use for things we have decided to keep calling by one name. Each answer sounds right until the other person in the conversation finds the case where it fails. That is why this one is better talked about than read about.

So are you still the same you?

The facts

What is checked, and where

Plutarch records that the Athenians preserved the ship of Theseus, replacing its decayed timbers, and that philosophers disputed whether it remained the same ship.
Source: Plutarch, Life of Theseus, section 23 (Internet Classics Archive, MIT)
Thomas Hobbes added a second ship, rebuilt from the original planks, which leaves two candidates for the original. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy walks through both versions of the puzzle.
Source: Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, "Material Constitution"
A red blood cell survives an average of 120 days, roughly four months, before it is broken down and replaced.
Source: American Society of Hematology, "Blood Basics"

Talk about it

If every part of you has been replaced, what makes you still you?

This is the kind of question that goes somewhere only when another person pushes back. A few ways in, if the first one stalls:

Is a band with none of its original members still the same band?
If you repaired an old phone until nothing original was left, would it still feel like yours?
Which matters more for being you: your memories, your body, or the people who know you?

On Mindfuse the other person is a real voice somewhere else in the world, and the call starts with one tap. Ask them what they make of it, then tell them yours. Talk to the world has more questions that work on a first call.

Ask someone far away.

A voice call with a real person in another country. Your first 3 days are unlimited. After that, one free conversation a day, whether you start it or answer it.

Download Mindfuse